| School | Location | Conf. | Head Coach |
|---|
| Baruch Bearcats | New York, NY | CUNYAC | Jose Torres (Baruch) |
| Brockport State Golden Eagles | Brockport, NY | SUNYAC | Justin Beach (Brockport State '03) |
| Cazenovia Wildcats | Cazenovia, NY | NEAC | Peter Way (Cazenovia '03) |
| CCNY Beavers | New York, NY | CUNYAC | Dave Yorke (Drew '96) |
| Clarkson Golden Knights | Potsdam, NY | LL | Jim Kane (Brockport State '95) |
| Cortland State Red Dragons | Cortland, NY | SUNYAC | Joe Brown (Ithaca '90) |
| D'Youville Spartans | Buffalo, NY | AMCC | Rob Kennuth (SUNY Brockport) |
| Farmingdale State Rams | Farmingdale, NY | SKY | Keith Osik (LSU) |
| Fredonia State Blue Devils | Fredonia, NY | SUNYAC | Matt Palisin (Penn State-Behrend '94) |
| Ithaca Bombers | Ithaca, NY | E8 | George Valesente (Ithaca '66) |
| John Jay Bloodhounds | New York, NY | CUNYAC | Dan Palumbo |
| Keuka Storm | Keuka Park, NY | NEAC | Seth Fikes (Keuka '04) |
| Lehman Lightning | Bronx, NY | CUNYAC | John Foster |
| Merchant Marine Mariners | Kings Point, NY | LAND | Michael Notebaert (Ithaca '03) |
| Mitchell Pequots | New London, CT | NECC | Len Farquhar |
| Mount St. Mary Knights | Newburgh, NY | SKY | Steve Sosler (Mount St. Mary (N.Y.) '99) |
| Mount St. Vincent Dolphins | Riverdale, NY | SKY | Steven Macias (Cortland State '90) |
| New Paltz State Hawks | New Paltz, NY | SUNYAC | Matt Griffiths (Marist '02) |
| Oneonta State Red Dragons | Oneonta, NY | SUNYAC | Rick Ferchen (Valparaiso '77) |
| Oswego State Lakers | Oswego, NY | SUNYAC | Frank Paino (Coastal Carolina '81) |
| Plattsburgh State Cardinals | Plattsburgh, NY | SUNYAC | Kris Doorey (Stony Brook '96) |
| Polytechnic Bluejays | Brooklyn, NY | SKY | Jose Vega |
| Rochester Yellowjackets | Rochester, NY | LL | Joe Reina (Long Island University '97) |
| Rochester Tech Tigers | Rochester, NY | E8 | Rob Grow (RIT '88) |
| RPI Red Hawks | Troy, NY | LL | Karl Steffen (Ithaca '78) |
| Skidmore Thoroughbreds | Saratoga Springs, NY | LL | Ron Plourde (St. Joseph's (Maine) '91) |
| St. John Fisher Cardinals | Pittsford, NY | E8 | Brandon Potter (St. John Fisher '04) |
| St. Joseph's (Bklyn.) Bears | Brooklyn, NY | IND | Scott Losche (Baruch '00) |
| St. Joseph's (L.I.) Golden Eagles | Patchogue, NY | SKY | Randy Caden |
| St. Lawrence Saints | Canton, NY | LL | Tom Fay (Ithaca '68) |
| Staten Island Dolphins | Staten Island, NY | CUNYAC | Mike Mauro (John Jay '90) |
| Stevens Ducks | Hoboken, NJ | E8 | John Crane (Rider '96) |
| SUNY-Maritime Privateers | Throggs Neck, NY | SKY | Eugene Steinbach (Georgia Southern) |
| SUNY-Old Westbury Panthers | Old Westbury, NY | SKY | John Lonardo (Queens College) |
| SUNY-Purchase Panthers | Purchase, NY | SKY | Bill Guerrero (Connecticut '93) |
| SUNYIT Wildcats | Utica, NY | NEAC | Kevin Edick (North Adams State) |
| Union Dutchmen | Schenectady, NY | LL | David Dagostino (Union '95) |
| Utica Pioneers | Utica, NY | E8 | Andrew Weimer (Le Moyne '03) |
| Vassar Brewers | Poughkeepsie, NY | LL | Jon Martin (Lynchburg '01) |
| Yeshiva Maccabees | New York, NY | SKY | Philip Kahn |
