| School | Location | Conf. | Head Coach |
|---|
| Augsburg Auggies | Minneapolis, MN | MIAC | Keith Bateman (Bethel '98) |
| Aurora Spartans | Aurora, IL | NATHC | Shaun Neitzel (William Penn '95) |
| Benedictine Eagles | Lisle, IL | NATHC | John Ostrowski (Lewis '70) |
| Bethany Lutheran Vikings | Mankato, MN | UMAC | Ryan Kragh (North Dakota ) |
| Bethel Royals | St. Paul, MN | MIAC | Greg Indlecoffer (Bethel '88) |
| Carleton Knights | Northfield, MN | MIAC | Aaron Rushing (Grinnell '01) |
| Concordia (Ill.) Cougars | River Forest, IL | NATHC | Spiro Lempesis (St. Mary's (Minn.) '88) |
| Concordia (Wis.) Falcons | Mequon, WI | NATHC | Val Keiper (Concordia Portland) |
| Concordia-Moorhead Cobbers | Moorhead, MN | MIAC | Bucky Burgau (North Dakota State '73) |
| Crown Storm | St. Bonifacius, MN | UMAC | Dan Nyquist (Northwestern (Minn) '08) |
| Dominican Stars | River Forest, IL | NATHC | Terry Casey (Dominican '97) |
| Edgewood Eagles | Madison, WI | NATHC | Al Brisack |
| Gustavus Adolphus Gusties | St. Peter, MN | MIAC | Mike Carroll (Mankato State '82) |
| Hamline Pipers | St. Paul, MN | MIAC | Jason Verdugo (Arizona State '97) |
| Lakeland Muskies | Sheboygan, WI | NATHC | Chris Thousand (Lakeland '02) |
| Macalester Scots | St. Paul, MN | MIAC | Matt Parrington (Mankato State '91) |
| Maranatha Baptist Crusaders | Watertown, WI | NATHC | Gary Garrison (Olivet Nazarene) |
| Marian Sabres | Fond du Lac, WI | NATHC | Jason Bartelt (Lakeland) |
| Martin Luther Knights | New Ulm, MN | UMAC | Randy Cox (Wisconsin Lutheran '91) |
| Milwaukee Engineering Raiders | Milwaukee, WI | NATHC | Troy Doering (UW-Milwaukee) |
| Minnesota-Morris Cougars | Morris, MN | UMAC | Mark Fohl (North Dakota '81) |
| North Central (Minn.) Rams | Minneapolis, MN | IND | Tim Beasley (Louisiana-Lafayette '07) |
| Northland Jacks | Ashland, WI | UMAC | Andy Ham (Husson '05) |
| Northwestern (Minn.) Eagles | St. Paul, MN | UMAC | Dave Hieb |
| Presentation Saints | Aberdeen, SD | UMAC | Alex Ferguson (Principia '03) |
| Rockford Regents | Rockford, IL | NATHC | Bob Koopmann (Harper) |
| St. John's Johnnies | Collegeville, MN | MIAC | Jerry Haugen (St. John's '76) |
| St. Mary's (Minn.) Cardinals | Winona, MN | MIAC | Nick Winecke (St. Mary's (Minn) '07) |
| St. Olaf Oles | Northfield, MN | MIAC | Matt McDonald (St. Olaf '89) |
| St. Scholastica Saints | Duluth, MN | UMAC | Corey Kemp (St. Scholastica '01) |
| St. Thomas Tommies | St. Paul, MN | MIAC | Chris Olean (St. Thomas) |
| UW-La Crosse Eagles | La Crosse, WI | WIAC | Chris Schwarz (UW-La Crosse '02) |
| UW-Oshkosh Titans | Oshkosh, WI | WIAC | Tom Lechnir (UW-Oshkosh '83) |
| UW-Platteville Pioneers | Platteville, WI | WIAC | Eric Frese (Mount Mercy) |
| UW-Stevens Point Pointers | Stevens Point, WI | WIAC | Pat Bloom (UW-Stevens Point '01) |
| UW-Stout Blue Devils | Menomonie, WI | WIAC | Seth Maier (UW-Stout '07) |
| UW-Superior Yellow Jackets | Superior, WI | WIAC | Eddy Morgan (St. Scholastica) |
| UW-Whitewater Warhawks | Whitewater, WI | WIAC | John Vodenlich (UW-Whitewater '92) |
| Wisconsin Lutheran Warriors | Milwaukee, WI | NATHC | Dave Reinemann (Wisconsin Lutheran '93) |
